If you're a Washington Redskins fan quarterback controversies are par for the course around these parts. Four seasons ago, to a person, the city believed Robert Griffin III was the savior of the franchise. It was blasphemy to believe otherwise. President Obama may have been in charge of the Executive Branch, but RGIII ran Washington D.C. Since Griffin's rookie campaign a combination of ill-timed injuries, coaching changes, and toxic management have landed him on the Redskins bench and in the national sports media's doghouse. Who would have thunk it a few seasons ago.
When it comes to the Redskins organization past is always prologue. The team has started 16 different quarterbacks over the past 16 years. Yet it speaks volumes about how the organization has been managed, particularly at the quarterback position. It's been a carousel marked by bad off-season signings, mediocre talent during the Steve Spurrier era (remember the old ball coach?), injuries, down to Donovan McNabb whose time had passed him by. If you go back even further, the numbers get worse. You don't have to be a General Manager to figure out, with a few exceptions, the cornerstone of any successful NFL team is the quarterback position. Over the years, say back to 2001, the franchises that have experienced enduring success have had the same quarterback for multiple seasons. The Steelers, Patriots, Packers, and Giants have won multiple Super Bowl championships. There are other factors that play a role in teams winning championships year after year, but the common thread -- indeed the cornerstone - is stability at the quarterback position.
I started the 2015 NFL season riding the Kirk Cousins bandwagon. I liked his poise in the pocket. He had decent footwork. By all accounts he had committed to improving his mechanics during the off-season. When Cousins faltered my primary defense was that I needed a larger sample size by which to judge his performance. Not emotionalism. And while I still prefer a larger body of work by which to judge Cousins, the numbers, thus far, are trending in the wrong direction:
2014: 6 games 1710 yds, 10 TDs 9 ints 86 QB rating
2015: 6 games 1420 yds, 6 TDs 8 ints 77 QB rating
Those stats give me pause. The players seems to really believe in Cousins, both as a leader and as a quarterback. I can almost hear legendary coach Joe Gibbs heaping praise upon Cousins as a true Redskin. But he has a penchant for throwing interceptions at the most inopportune moments during the game. He's wildly inaccurate at times. The ball is either too high or behind the receiver. He doesn't appear to have the arm to make throws outside the numbers either. In back-to-back games Cousins has thrown an errant pass that was intercepted. Over time such bad decisions add up and can break the morale of any locker room. I've heard theories and excuses for the last two games. The ball simply didn't get there. I'm not sure where the Redskins should go from here. Colt McCoy's numbers are pedestrian at best. Robert Griffin III possesses a uniquely different skill set that presents a different host of issues, in my view.
I'll continue to hold onto hope and believe that Cousins has some upside. That he's under performing and these mistakes are correctable. That all sounds crazy. By definition that's what being a fan is. You're irrational. Fanatical. If I based my love for the Redskins on facts and results, I would have left them long ago. I'm not giving up on Kirk Cousins just yet, but the clock is ticking.